noprob agency logo
Request information
Comparison

Shopify vs Magento: What Each One Asks You to Run, and When to Stay on Magento

Shopify vs Magento is a choice about who runs the store: your team or the platform. Adobe’s and Shopify’s dates, limits and prices below were read on their official pages on 17 November 2026.

Antonio Manitta12 min read
Abstract dotted cover for the article on Shopify vs Magento

Shopify vs Magento comes down to who runs the store. On Magento your team runs the software, the servers under it and every upgrade. On Shopify, Shopify does, and you work inside its model. For most brands that sell to consumers I would pick Shopify. For a smaller group Magento is still the right answer, and I will say who they are.

We are noprob agency, a Shopify agency, so check me on the facts. Every date, limit and price below comes from Adobe’s Experience League documentation and from Shopify’s official pages, read on 17 November 2026 and linked where I use them. There is no feature grid here: your Magento cost is in your own invoices. The decision rests on four things that do not map one to one (product types, store views, extensions and B2B) and on one calendar: Adobe’s support dates.

A note on names. Magento Open Source is the open-source edition and Adobe Commerce is the commercial product from Adobe; where I write Magento, I mean both. If you have already decided to move and want the how, read the Magento to Shopify migration guide. If WordPress is on your list too and the question is Shopify vs WooCommerce vs Magento, start from Shopify vs WooCommerce: five decisions that settle it and come back here.

Which is better, Shopify or Magento?

Shopify is better for a brand that wants its people selling, and Magento is better for a company whose advantage lives in custom logic that its own team maintains. That is my judgement after more than 7 years of eCommerce projects. In practice:

My rule: choose a platform by the list of things your store does today that the other one would make you rebuild.

What does each one cost to run for three years?

Over three years Shopify costs a published subscription plus fees, and Magento costs what your team, your hosting and your upgrades cost, which no public page can tell you. So the figure for Magento is the one in your last twelve months of invoices: every number online is somebody else’s store. Three years is the right window for both, because Adobe supports each version for three years and Shopify Plus has a 3-year term.

On Magento, count five lines:

On Shopify the lines are public. The Shopify Plus plan page lists $2,300 a month on a 3-year term or $2,500 on a 1-year term (from €2,100 a month in euros). Those prices are "for standard setups and integrations": for more complex, higher-volume companies Shopify says "there might be a variable platform fee". If you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, Plus adds a 0.2% third-party transaction fee. Apps and any partner work come on top. The plans below Plus are on shopify.com/pricing.

Shopify’s own comparison says its total cost of ownership is, on average, 29% better than Adobe Commerce’s, based on research it commissioned in North America between December 2023 and January 2024. Read it as what it is, a vendor’s claim about other companies. My rule: take your last twelve months of invoices for hosting, licence, extensions, developers and agency, multiply by three and add one version upgrade. That is your Magento number. The one-off cost of moving is a separate line, explained in what a Shopify migration costs.

Who maintains what: hosting, updates, security

On Magento you maintain the software and, unless you buy Adobe’s managed service, the servers under it; on Shopify the platform is hosted and updated by Shopify. The clearest way to see what that means is Adobe’s lifecycle policy: "Adobe offers a three-year standard support window from the General Availability (GA) date for each version". These are the dates for the 2.4 line.

Adobe Commerce 2.4 support dates, from Adobe’s lifecycle policy (read on 17 November 2026)
VersionReleasedStandard support endsWhere it stands on 17 November 2026
2.4.912 May 202631 May 2029Standard support
2.4.88 April 202531 May 2028Standard support
2.4.79 April 202431 May 2027Standard support, then extended support until 31 May 2028
2.4.614 March 202311 August 2026Extended support until 31 August 2027, then security fixes only until 31 May 2028
2.4.59 August 202212 August 2025Security fixes only until 31 May 2027
2.4.412 April 202212 April 2025Security fixes only until 31 May 2027

Adobe says the last period "provides limited isolated security fixes only (no quality fixes)" and "will not be extended beyond the published dates". So if you are on 2.4.4 or 2.4.5, 31 May 2027 goes in your calendar today, whichever platform you choose.

Then there is the stack. For 2.4.9 on your own servers, Adobe’s system requirements list PHP 8.5, MySQL 8.4 or MariaDB 12.3, OpenSearch 3, RabbitMQ 4.3, Valkey 9, Varnish 8 and Composer 2.10 (the install tool), and the page states that "Adobe supports only the system requirement combinations listed". That is six services to keep on the right version, besides Magento itself. On Adobe Commerce on cloud infrastructure Adobe releases the core code updates, but its shared responsibility page is plain: "applying patches is the merchant’s responsibility".

None of this is anybody’s fault. It is what running your own software means, and some teams do it very well. On Shopify that list is not yours: there is no version to upgrade and no server to patch. What stays yours is the storefront code, the apps you install and your data.

What does Magento do that Shopify does not?

Magento gives you seven product types, a hierarchy of websites, stores and store views, and full control of the code, and none of the three has a one-to-one equivalent on Shopify. These are the points where I would look at your store before giving you an answer.

If a product of yours needs a fourth option, or your prices change at website level, that is a design decision to take before you choose a platform, not after.

What does Shopify do that Magento does not?

Shopify takes hosting, updates and checkout off your list, and puts you on the platform merchants are moving to. The first part saves you work. The second matters for hiring, apps and what comes next.

One opinion of mine goes with this list: the game changer is speed. A store moves its numbers when the page loads fast and when your team can change it without opening a ticket, much more than when it changes from white to black.

B2B and multi-store: Shopify Plus vs Adobe Commerce

On B2B and multi-store, Shopify Plus vs Adobe Commerce is the comparison to make, and the steps of your order decide it. Adobe Commerce documents a B2B extension with company accounts, shared catalogs, negotiable quotes, requisition lists, Quick Order and purchase order approvals. For several sites it uses the hierarchy above, inside one installation.

Shopify B2B is available on Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus, with limits that Shopify lists in its B2B plan features: 3 catalog assignments across your active B2B markets on the standard plans, unlimited on Plus. Three things are on Plus only: catalogs assigned directly to a company or a location, deposit requirements and partial payments. Plus also runs separate checkout flows for B2B and consumers in the same store.

For several stores, Plus expansion stores are independent stores: settings, products, collections and inventory do not sync by default, and apps are billed per store. They are meant as an extension of the main brand, with the same name and the same goods; different brands need a multi-brand agreement, with one Plus subscription per brand. Have the billing currency of the expansion stores confirmed in your contract. A Magento store view for a language or a currency usually needs none of this: it becomes a market inside one Shopify store.

My rule: write down a real B2B order, step by step (quote, approval, deposit, payment terms), and check every step on both platforms. Negotiable quotes and requisition lists are the two I would check first: if your buyers use them every day, look at how they would work on Shopify before you sign. What changes on Plus, contract included, is in our Shopify Plus migration article.

When should you stay on Magento?

Stay on Magento when the value of your store is in custom logic that works today and a team of your own keeps it working. I say it as someone who migrates stores for a living: these are the cases where I would tell you to stay.

If you stay, put the money where it protects you: the upgrade calendar from the table above, with the date written down and an owner next to it.

When should you move, and how long does it take?

Move when keeping Magento current costs you more than what is custom is worth, and plan it on Adobe’s dates. The signs are usually these:

Our Magento to Shopify migration service is the Shopify Launch Sprint: a migration to Shopify in 14 days with our Custom AI System, go-live between day 15 and day 30, 90 days of support and 4 written guarantees. The first one reads: "Store ready on day 14 or we refund the first installment." The price is public and set by your revenue: €5,800 under €2M, €8,800 from €2M to €20M, €12,800 above €20M, VAT excluded, in 4 installments.

The method is conservative. First we move what already works from A to B, without drastic changes; a redesign can come later, with a designer. A custom need, such as a pricing rule or a product that does not fit three options, I study after the first call and come back with a clear answer. Cumini, a luxury multibrand boutique, is an example of a store that left a platform tied to its ERP: live on Shopify on 19 May 2025, with online sales up 67.7% from June 2025 to May 2026 on the twelve months before.

How product types, store views, modules and URLs are handled one by one is in the Magento to Shopify migration guide. The order in which products, customers and orders are loaded is in Shopify data migration, and the method that is the same on every platform is in our guide to migrating to Shopify.

Next step. Send us your store: apply to the Shopify Launch Sprint and we reply within 48 hours with your tier, the price and the first available kickoff date.

Frequently asked questions

Is Magento the same as Adobe Commerce?

No: Magento Open Source is the open-source edition, with its source code published under the OSL 3.0 licence. Adobe Commerce is the commercial product from Adobe, which you can run on your own servers, on Adobe-managed cloud infrastructure or as a fully managed cloud service. The gift card product type and the B2B extension belong to Adobe Commerce.

Is Magento still supported in 2026?

Yes: Adobe gives each version three years of standard support from its release. On 17 November 2026, versions 2.4.7, 2.4.8 and 2.4.9 are in standard support, until 31 May 2027, 31 May 2028 and 31 May 2029. Version 2.4.6 is in extended support until 31 August 2027, and 2.4.4 and 2.4.5 receive security fixes only until 31 May 2027. The source is Adobe’s lifecycle policy.

Is Shopify cheaper than Magento?

It depends on what your team, hosting and upgrades cost today. Shopify publishes its prices: Shopify Plus is $2,300 a month on a 3-year term or $2,500 on a 1-year term. Magento has no single public figure, because most of the cost is hosting, patches, version upgrades, extensions and developers. Add up your last twelve months of invoices and compare three years.

Can Shopify handle B2B like Adobe Commerce?

For many B2B stores, yes. Shopify B2B is available on Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus, with companies and catalogs; catalogs assigned directly to a company, deposits and partial payments are on Plus only. Adobe Commerce documents a B2B extension with company accounts, shared catalogs, negotiable quotes, requisition lists, Quick Order and purchase order approvals. Check each step of your real B2B order on both.

What are the disadvantages of Magento?

The work around it: each version has a three-year support window, so version upgrades are a recurring project. On your own servers you keep PHP, the database, OpenSearch, RabbitMQ, Valkey and Varnish on the versions Adobe supports, and on Adobe’s cloud infrastructure applying patches is still the merchant’s responsibility.

How long does a Magento to Shopify migration take?

With the Shopify Launch Sprint the store is ready on day 14 and goes live between day 15 and day 30, followed by 90 days of support. What makes a Magento project heavier is the number of store views, custom modules and B2B rules, so those are inventoried before the calendar starts.

Decide on the calendar and on the code

Two things settle Shopify vs Magento for your store: the date your version leaves support, and how much of your code does something only you do. If the date is close and the code is mostly standard, move. If the date is far and the code is your advantage, stay, and keep the upgrades on schedule.

The Shopify Launch Sprint moves your store to Shopify in 14 days with our Custom AI System: a fixed calendar, a public price and 4 written guarantees.

Antonio Manitta

Antonio Manitta

Founder & eCommerce Manager at NoProb Agency

For over 7 years I have helped fashion, supplements, and DTC brands scale their eCommerce. I work in long-term partnership with three brands at a time, building stable systems that compound.

About NoProb →

Ready to fix what's slowing you down?

Avatar
Book a call
Antonio replies personally